“U.S. defends secretive Mississippi ICE raids as local, state officials decry effect on children,” blared the headline in the Washington Post, after ICE arrested hundreds of illegal aliens working at meatpacking plants in Mississippi. The Post coverage was just one of many that focused on the impact of immigration enforcement on the children of the people who were arrested for violating federal laws.
A thousand miles or so away, in Colorado Springs, Colorado, immigration policies separated another father from his five children. In this case, Sean Buchanan’s children will never see him again because he is dead. Buchanan was killed on Aug. 2 while riding his motorcycle, when a car swerved into his lane.
The car was driven by Miguel Ramirez Valiente, an illegal
alien from El Salvador. But there’s more to the story. Ramirez Valiente was
driving with a revoked license. The revocation was a result of a 2018
conviction for drunk driving, and one day earlier he had been denied
reinstatement of his license because he had failed to complete alcohol therapy
and fulfill his community service obligations. He apparently wasn’t such a
great guy off the road either. Ramirez Valiente was twice charged with reckless
endangerment and domestic violence, although in both cases the charges were
Yet, Ramirez Valiente, an illegal alien with a pending
deportation order was still behind the wheel on a Colorado highway, without a
license, when he struck and killed Buchanan. He managed to do this because he
had a lot of help. Among those who aided and abetted in this tragedy are the
virtue-signalers at the All Souls Unitarian Universalist Church in Colorado
Springs, who earlier this year allowed him to hole-up in their basement to make
sure that if ICE arrested him they would have to do so under the worst possible
The justification for Ramirez Valiente dodging the consequences of his illegal behavior, and for his enablers, was, of course, the children. “My three children and I are terrified that he will be deported. His children need him. So do I,” said his wife in a tearful news conference in January. Likewise, Ramirez Valiente himself invoked his kids as a reason why he should be exempt from the consequences of his actions. “I can’t be separated from them. I have always worked hard to support my family, and they depend on me,” he pleaded. The church’s pastor, Rev. Nori Rost, castigated the government as being immoral for attempting to enforce immigration laws
Ramirez Valiente was also the beneficiary of good timing. In June, Gov. Jared Polis signed a bill making Colorado a sanctuary state, which may have provided Ramirez Valiente the confidence that he could resume his normal life – outside the church basement – which included driving without a license, without concern for fellow motorists. Under Colorado’s sanctuary law, Ramirez Valiente did not need to be concerned even after he killed Buchanan. The Colorado State Patrol questioned him at the scene and released him, even though he was driving without a license.
Now, back to the kids in Mississippi. They are deserving of our empathy, just as all children who suffer the consequences of their parents’ mistakes and illegal actions do. Anyone who does not feel for kids in such situations is heartless. But anyone who thinks that we should exempt people from the consequences of violating laws because they have children and other family members is dangerously foolish.
Nevertheless, the news coverage was primarily focused on how
the enforcement of laws against lawbreakers affects their kids. There was even
scant coverage of the role played by scofflaw employers who bypassed legal U.S.
workers to man their plants, and instead helped themselves to an illegal labor
subsidy at the expense of taxpayers.
Will we see an equal outpouring of concern in the media for
the five now father-less Buchanan kids? Will they be comforted, much less
receive an apology from Rev. Rost? Will Gov. Polis and the Colorado Legislature
reconsider the policies that made Ramirez Valiente feel confident that the laws
of the United States and the state of Colorado don’t apply to him? Don’t bet on